Skip to main content
Culture

“I Always Struggled Being Evaluated – When [You’re] Longlisted For The Booker, [Evaluation] Happens On A Very Large Scale”: Djamel White On His Breakthrough All Them Dogs

The Booker nominee’s All Them Dogs brings homoeroticism to Dublin gangland. Sitting down with fellow Irish author Colin Walsh, the 28-year-old discusses the life and literature that inspired it.

“There’s often this tendency for journalists to want to talk about the most abstract theme” of a piece of culture, says Colin Walsh. In the case of Djamel White’s Booker Prize-nominated underworld noir, All Them Dogs, it’s “masculinity” that would appear to be filling column inches. However, “I don’t think anyone who’s sitting down to write fiction is saying, ‘This is going to be a stirring meditation on masculinity.’” 

White agrees – approaching fiction like that can “deaden a novel,” he reflects. Tony, the protagonist and colloquial narrator of the Irish writer’s March hit, arrives back in Dublin after five years on the run, with a drive to return to his former life. With his one-time mentor dead, he finds himself working under crime boss Aengus Lavelle and, crucially, in the protective company of Aengus’ top enforcer, Tony’s once-shy, compliant classmate Darren “Flute” Walsh. However, tasked with the murder of a substandard dealer, their collusion becomes knotted with complex desire for each other. 

Yet Walsh – whose 2023 thriller-meets-coming-of-age debut Kala won him the Irish Book Award for Newcomer of the Year – also points out: Tony’s relationships with men are central to much of the book’s tension. But rather than setting out to write a masculinity thesis, All Them Dogs is “reflective of the world as I know it and relationships as I’ve known them,” White explains. 

Growing up on an estate in Dublin, White encountered Tony’s world at arm’s length: crossing paths with its inhabitants, hearing rumours of its happenings or being woken as a child by events unravelling on his doorstep. “I wrote the characters in a way that felt true to me,” he says. “So you can find themes [like masculinity in the book] in the same way you can find these themes in the fabric of your everyday life.” 

Colin Walsh: Purely as a reader, to me, All Them Dogs is a real novel of voice. The entire world is being conjured by that voice. Were there certain writers or books that gave you permission to enter your story in a voice like that? 

Djamel White: I think the first novel that I read that I was like, ‘Oh, I could do something like this’ – when I was still developing as a writer, which I still am – was Cherry by Nico Walker. But even predating that, when I was a teenager and reading Bukowski, I was taken by the voice in his books, and the employment of colloquialisms to deliver still really effective, gut-wrenching sentences. And then, of course, obviously, Roddy [Doyle], as an example that you can write in this dialogue, and people respond well to recognising themselves in the language of a book.

I had been playing with the first few paragraphs of this Dublin neo-noir thing about a relationship between two men, and I wasn’t sure about the quality of that relationship, but I definitely wanted to explore characters by putting these two men together and forcing them to connect. Then when I found Tony's voice, which was really [by] trying and seeing what would stick, he became an engine for a story to unfold because, as someone who operates with blinders on and as someone who expects a certain level of respect and responds to whether or not he thinks he’s receiving it, he himself is the escalator. 

It became this series of episodes where Tony would encounter someone, and he would emerge from that encounter, and whether or not it was worth keeping in the novel would be determined way later. So the early drafts are episodic. It was a bit of a 'freak of the week' element where Tony would come up against somebody who operates in the same space as him, and he would cast his judgments and respond to whatever they were asking him to do. For me, that was me figuring out how Tony ticks, and how he expects others to respond to him. So, voice was at the forefront from the beginning.

CW: In many ways, the emotional and narrative engines of the book are rooted in the dynamics between Tony and another man – whether it’s with [his straightened-out former best friend] Kenny Boyle or [his half-brother] Archie. In that interplay between the two characters, each of those people is dimensionalising Tony in a certain way.  

DW: You make a good observation there – all of his relationships with other men are also a reflection on where he places himself. He’s discussing every ideal or every version of a man that each of the men in his life represents. He has a certain reaction to it that then feeds back on his view of himself. So he’s disgusted by Kenny and Archie, and yet he’s in total admiration of Flute. I think that speaks to how those types of men have made him feel throughout his whole life. And he’s rejected by Archie, and Archie represents all these qualities that he doesn’t have. So when he sees qualities in Kenny that are maybe reminiscent of qualities that he’s seen in Archie, he’s immediately disgusted by that because of what a man should be to him.

CW: There are a lot of contemporary novels and contemporary TV where you can feel this kind of schematic, agenda-based writing that every character is meant to represent a certain position and that certain values and arguments are always going to win the day, etc. In the last few years, there’s almost been a purity test for characters, but Tony is the total opposite of that.

There’s a line from the really awful brother-in-law in Fleabag where he says something like, ‘I’m not a bad guy, I just have a bad personality.’ But Tony’s a pretty bad guy, and he also has a pretty bad personality. There’s no situation he can’t escalate further into a disaster. What was it that made you feel like this person is the vehicle for the story – this person, who is so contrary to any reassuring platitudinous things that your typical middle-class reader is going to be looking for?

DW: I don’t have great answers to that, other than I have known people like this, and I’ve wondered where the emotional undercurrent is, and what drives their actions. And from the outset, you think this is id, pleasure-seeking behaviour. There’s something more to that. There’s got to be a wanting to belong underneath that, and there has to be a commonality in it. I think the reason the readers who enjoy the book stay on side with Tony is that there’s something in what he wants that they can recognise, which is that, even though he won’t admit it, he feels isolated. He can’t figure out why he feels isolated, but ultimately he wants communion and connection in the same way everybody does, so that makes sense of his actions in a kind of twisted way. It was a risk writing something like that. But he’s not evil.

CW: No, he’s not evil. The novel itself is doing something quite different to what I, in a crude way, would call the more typical novel where you’ve got a working-class central character. Often those novels are about someone who’s basically, internally, a middle-class character just waiting to realise themselves and then leave it all behind. 

DW: Yes! 

CW: Very often, [those books] seem much more concerned about reaffirming the values of the prospective readers of those stories than speaking to the truth of a situation of someone like Tony, for example. To what extent do you feel like Tony’s inability or unwillingness to transcend the bind within which he finds himself actually reflects something that’s very contemporary – this idea of there being no way out? People are stuck.

DW: I think it’s wholly personal for Tony, and what the class depiction in the novel is. I wanted to depict something where the lines are blurred. With my experience of suburban Dublin, those lines are blurred. The middle class and working class blend together quite easily, especially in the areas where the book is set. 

While I recognise all of the social issues that can lock a person into place, the novel is really about an individual’s position in that world and the trappings of their own. Not to say that Tony’s a victim of his own mentality, but there’s a mentality that seeps in because of the relationships that he’s had with men, or the lack of relationships that he’s had with men.

He’s ultimately doing what he thinks he wants at all times. There’s no wishing to get out of this. So the question is: Why is this the pinnacle of existence that he’s set for himself? And it’s down to the relationships he's had as a young man with other men, and what values have been instilled in him.

CW: There's something Oscar Wilde said that I don't know if you would agree or disagree with, but he said, ‘In every first novel, the hero is the author as either Christ or Faust.’ A very Oscar Wilde thing to say [laughs]. To what extent would that apply to the relationship between Tony and yourself? What’s your sense of your relationship to Tony?

DW: At the start, it was a kind of exercise in empathy. You’ll know this yourself: writing fiction, all the characters are complicated versions of people and other characters, but also myself. My worst instincts that aren’t acted on. The intrusive aspects of oneself, or maybe even just a burden. I don’t want to tarnish myself [laughs]. 

But there are definitely darker aspects of myself that are present within Tony, along with many of the desires, and ones I would have had as a young person, and a certain youthful indignance maybe. I can relate to a lot of Tony’s feelings, even though they’re obviously written to the extreme. But at a base level, there’s no reaction that he’d had that I didn’t find unreachable. 

CW: Absolutely. I get frustrated sometimes when there’s a contemporary vogue for people to collapse fiction into veiled autobiography, which I just fundamentally disagree with. But, on another level, I do feel like when you read a novel, you’re seeing someone exploring character, human nature, and the dilemmas that they choose and the responses that they take or avoid in the writing. All of these things reveal something of the writer. Do you feel like the writing of All Them Dogs, just the actual journey, revealed anything to you of yourself that you were surprised by?

DW: I’m not sure. Maybe the truth might be more revealed over the course of a couple of novels, as more patterns emerge.

There are relationships depicted in the novel that if I spoke too much about my place in those, it would involve talking about people that can't defend themselves. But I’m always cautious with that as well because the book doesn’t stop with just me. So yes, getting to the end of it, it did shine some light on some of the relationships I've had, or still have, or don't have anymore that have disintegrated.

CW: You write your first book in a state of innocence. It really is just you, and a Word document, and the door to the room is closed. But then when you publish your book, it becomes an artefact out in the world. Anybody who wants can come in. How have you been managing that shift? 

DW: Well, especially with access to the internet, first of all, you’re being referred to by your surname, which is crazy to begin with [laughs]. But also – being evaluated. I always struggled with being evaluated. That’s why I didn’t take up team sport. And, of course, when you get longlisted for a prize like the Booker, [evaluation] happens on a very large scale. And the best part is that there are a lot of readers who really resonate with the book. It’s not even that I care that the novel is criticised or that people don’t like it because you accept that from the get-go – but, I suppose there’ll always be this feeling that it’s you that’s being evaluated or measured against, and that there's a certain worth that comes with that. One word that kept coming up was ‘worthy’. ‘This is worthy of the long list,’ and that’s such a psychological word. 

CW: Whenever people are insisting on something’s worthiness, there’s an implicit sense that someone is saying it isn’t. Do you think that on some level, if that was coming up for you and for your book, that that’s actually a class thing, about the voice or the world of the book?

DW: No, my reading of it is that it’s the classic novel vs literature debate. The fact that this is, in many respects, a novel. I’ve seen reviews that have been like, ‘The voice wrecked my head. I hated the way this person talked.’ And I was like, 'Well, that says a lot about you.' That’s water off a duck’s back with me, because some reviews and responses are so revealing of the person writing them that it doesn't even read as criticism. 

CW: That [is] really insightful – it’s not snobbery on the basis of class, but this literary versus genre binary. People like to pretend that there isn’t this ghettoisation that happens. But it is very prevalent in the book world, this hard and fast separation of what is literary and what is genre. If you actually delve into any individual book, you can pick that apart very quickly. It’s still in operation in how people respond to books. Was that a question at all in the writing, or did that come the closer you got to the world of publishing?

DW: Writing this book, I knew that if it was published, I’d want you to find it in the fiction section of the bookshop, not the crime section. And I wouldn’t want it to have had a cover that is indicative of a crime paperback because that didn’t feel like the identity of the book. Also, I was conscious it wouldn’t reach the right reader. And I think somebody who wanted a crime thriller, in the vein of what you would find in that section, would be disappointed picking up this book – or pleasantly surprised, I don’t know. But I wanted to find the readers that would appreciate it.

CW: In terms of yourself as a person, as Djamel White – you’ve lived this whole life, which is open-ended, going in all directions, and then you’re seeing this kind of avatar of yourself, like a public figure. Can you talk to me a little bit about that?

DW: I don’t recognise myself in the person I read, in other people’s words and in the videos that are edited in a certain way, and so I don’t watch them back, and I don’t read them. It's just easier that way.

There was a desire to be seen before I was published, and then there’s [now] also the desire to withdraw. But part of that is [being] flattened by someone else’s viewpoint. It can never be a complete picture.

CW: In a world where people are constantly talking about how men don’t read anymore, what has literature actually brought you?

DW: For me, my most memorable experiences with books are books that I truly escaped into, and it all goes back to the feeling of reading as a child, which was completely unacademic. It was pure escapism. That’s the experience I look for when I’m reading. I recently finished – it’s trendy at the moment, and I’m so glad it is because I wouldn’t have read it otherwise – Lonesome Dove [by Larry McMurtry]. I was like, ‘I just finished a 1000-page book, and I feel like I just returned home.

It’s probably the same feeling you get as a kid when you’re reading Lord of the Rings, and you’re like, ‘I’m battle-worn, I’m weary, my feet are tired, and I’ve lost so many people along the way.’ That’s the feeling I chase when I read. 

CW: I do find it interesting that there are books like Lonesome Dove or East of Eden that are getting this whole lease of life from TikTok. 

DW: It’s fascinating that near 1,000-page books are the ones everybody is reading based on a TikTok algorithm where videos are under a minute. It almost looks like people are getting recommendations for these really long experiences out of these short-form experiences that their body is rejecting. It's like, ‘Get off this fucking thing. Look at this huge book that you’re gonna love. And you can come back here and tell us all that you read it’ [laughs].

CW: Exactly [laughs]. You’ve talked elsewhere about being the first serious reader in your family, and I have the same thing for me. The majority of people in my life don’t read. It’s such a basic question, but I actually think it could be really helpful to people who might read this interview – could you give three recommendations of books that you would give to someone who feels like reading literature is not for them?

DW: I would recommend – for a big book – Alone in Berlin. It’s one of those examples where there are all of these richly realised characters. It depicts a point in history from the inside, which is fascinating, and it’s ordinary people trying to survive and make a life of meaning in Nazi Germany, which is, on the face of it, blessed in empathy and nuance and love. It’s got all of the essential human emotions and stories. [Pauses to think] Gosh, I always try to recommend books that I haven’t recommended before. Commonwealth by Ann Patchett keeps coming up. 

And again, it’s one of those things where it’s a tapestry. It’s written non-chronologically for the most part, so it deals with memory a lot and different characters’ perspectives on different events throughout life. But it’s about a family, and it’s an intergenerational story and accessible. She writes in a way that’s disarming, and funny, and full of life. And then, the third book, [picking from] the imaginary bookshelf… another favourite is The Round House by Louise Erdrich. It’s a coming-of-age story based on a Native American reservation, and it’s written in the ’80s about a young man whose mother is brutally raped by this white guy, and so at the same time as being a coming-of-age story, this young man is also trying to piece together the clues of what happened and potentially take out revenge, and again, it’s a really alive novel. 

All Them Dogs by Djamel White is published by John Murray Press. 

Interview by

Colin Walsh

Photography by

Bríd O'Donovan
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter
↳ SIGN UP for the Man About Town newsletter